|
||||||
Title: Can CH be managed? Post by LeLimey on Aug 4th, 2006, 10:24am Flash has agreed this would make a great stand alone post rather than tacking it on to another thread. I am finding it intriguing and I thought you all might too. In Flash's words from here on in: Science is continually demonstarting to us that X medication works because it has Y impact on the frequency/severity/duration of the attacks. But I am skeptical of this, because they do not tend to track the results longer term. The bulk of the people reading and posting to this forum are on medication. So I thought it would be interesting to let them see what happens without any meds at all. Sure if you just ignore the beast then things will turn nasty, but once you find out what the beast wants, and start feeding it, then things are much more managable. I've discovered that sometimes my body is telling me "just leave me alone to lie in bed", and it really doesn't want to get up. Eating my breakfast, having my morning shower, and getting dressed can be very difficult, but then SUDDENLY the shadows lift, and I can go the whole day with little or no activity. Pretty certain that had I lain in bed it would be one attack after the other. Sleeping felt natural but it WASN'T what the beast wanted. Would be interesting to see if other people experience similar, but only useful without any medications clouding the issue. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by LeLimey on Aug 4th, 2006, 10:25am Here is Flash's diary to date which can be read in full here (http://www.clusterheadaches.com/cgi-bin/yabb/YaBB.cgi?board=meds;action=display;num=1152553321) Quote:
Quote:
|
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by LeLimey on Aug 4th, 2006, 10:27am Quote:
|
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by LeLimey on Aug 4th, 2006, 10:28am Quote:
|
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by LeLimey on Aug 4th, 2006, 10:30am Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by LeLimey on Aug 4th, 2006, 10:31am Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by LeLimey on Aug 4th, 2006, 10:32am Quote:
|
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by Katherinecm on Aug 4th, 2006, 10:37am I think this is definitely a legitimate idea and something that should be considered and used if it works and if you're having low-level hits. But for those of us with families in political or government jobs who can't fool around with illegal substances and for who RC seeds work intermittently at best, I have to say I would be suicidal having constant KIP-10's without managed pain. That's not to say I'm drugged out all the time. Even taking a lortab once or twice a week is enough of a relief for me psychologically. I'm looking for some kind of preventative that works- any kind- herbal, vitamins, diet, I'll try it all, barring something that will end the career of someone I love. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by LeLimey on Aug 4th, 2006, 10:40am I have a question too.. does O2 count as a "med" in this scenario? ie could you use it to abort whilst still trying to follow the rest of the guidelines? |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by vig on Aug 4th, 2006, 10:47am cool! thanks Flash and Helen.... I went 2 years without medicine for CH.... that was when I advanced from Episodic to CHronic. every episode (I Have 4 a year, 6 weeks to 2 months) progressively got worse, more intense HA's and LONGER, until it all blurred into one big CH mess. So be careful. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by pattik on Aug 4th, 2006, 10:49am Good thread idea, Helen. As a 26+ year episodic CH'er, the only time I have ever tried preventative meds was a two week stint with lithium about 10 years ago. I have refrained from using preventative meds since then and relied only on abortives strictly as a personal choice. So "listening" to the beastie has come naturally to me for a long time. O2, ice, and caffeine are my friends--as well as a well-timed small meal or some extra exercise. I know what you mean about doing something which may go a little against your usual routine, but ends up shortening a hit. These experiences are all good tools for the arsenal. I can't compare my episodes with anyone else's. No two people experience things the same way. But based on all the reading I have done here over the years of other's experiences, I think I'm doing pretty well at manageing my CH. Patti |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by georgej on Aug 4th, 2006, 12:23pm I'm a forty-year episodic, and have been unmedicated (other than melatonin and magnesium supplements) for many years. While my cycles continue, they've decreased in frequency, from twice a year to once every three years. Is it because I chose not to use medication? I can't say. I will say, however, that this apparent natural process is at least manageable. I'd be extremely reluctant to medicate with something that fiddles with the mechanism of these headaches, whatever that might be. Thanks for the log, Helen and Flash--it's fascinating, and it's information like this that may enable us to get a handle on this thing, eventually. Best regards, George |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by TxBasslady on Aug 4th, 2006, 3:31pm on 08/04/06 at 12:23:40, georgej wrote:
This is exactly how I feel. I am convinced the more you mess with it, the worse it gets. I am one who chooses to go med free. Exception here is 02. When I went off everything last Dec and got the 02, it was by far, the best thing I had ever done. I found mixing combinations of whatever...was not the thing to do. The last triptan for me was in Jan., 2004. I have no cycle..even though I'm episodic. I may go 3 or 4 weeks with no sign of CH. Then there's times I get hit 2 or 3 times in a week. This is manageable to me, and I'm comfortable with the 02 as an abortive. Thanks for the post Helen...very interesting. Jean |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by CHTom on Aug 4th, 2006, 4:11pm What is the connection between defecating and urinating and CH pain? While most of us urinate several times a day, we usually only defecate once a day unless we are taking laxatives. For myself, either of these two acts has no effect upon my CH pain. Please explain your reasoning between defecating and urinating and CH pain and are laxatives used to increase the frequency of defecation. Thanks. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by LeLimey on Aug 4th, 2006, 4:24pm For the benefit of new people CHTom is our resident troll. He serves no purpose except to confuse, obfuscate and distress posters while providing a wealth of misinformation of his own. The best response to him is no response. All we do is inform people as best we can that his posts are unsound. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by CHTom on Aug 4th, 2006, 4:29pm I think that my questions are quite simple and straight forward, Helen. If you want to always label me as a "troll", that is fine, If you can't answer the question, then admit it. Does anyone have an answer? thanks. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by thebbz on Aug 4th, 2006, 8:20pm Maybe thats how to tell weather your coming or going? [smiley=laugh.gif] [smiley=laugh.gif] [smiley=laugh.gif] [smiley=laugh.gif] jb |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by lashultz on Aug 4th, 2006, 8:40pm [quote author=LeLimey link=board=meds;num=1154701446;start=0#0 date=08/04/06 at 10:24:05 Sure if you just ignore the beast then things will turn nasty, but once you find out what the beast wants, and start feeding it, then things are much more managable. I do agree a lot with what is said. I do know if I try to sleep in at times that I get hit a lot. But why should anyone have to put up with this type of pain. Are we managing the headaches or are they managing us. If we cannot sleep in when we want to or stay up late. Who is winning us or the beast. I for one say the beast is still in control at this point. I am not saying that I myself, don't try to go to bed at the same time and awake at the same time, to avoid getting hit. But I think at that point the beast is managing me not me managing the beast. Lee [/quote] |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by unsolved1 on Aug 5th, 2006, 2:35am Quote:
I guarantee there's a link between clusters & Histamine. Histamine desensitization is still helping me ;;D UNsolved |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by Flash on Aug 7th, 2006, 10:07am Went right through Friday evening with no hits. Head was feeling pretty solid. Then a migraine started at 3am. When I say migraine I'm referring to a migraine type headache that in my case is induced as a side effect of the CH. The migraine typically never gets beyond Kip5, and usually bopbbles along at kip2-4. It lasts for hours on end, and that's the worst thing about it. Whereas I can usually abort a cluster attack with exercise, food, water, tea, whatever... the migraine is a stubborn bastard. Not nearly as painful though. But includes a little nausea. Anyway this migraine ran from 3am on Saturday right through until 1am Sunday without a break. There were no CH attacks during this time though. I was able to sleep through the first part of it, although was aware of it's presence. The rest of the day it was just a total pain in the ass. Was hoping this was me reaching the peak of the episode, because my peak usually involves a low level migraine running in the background with high level and long duration CH hits breaking through. But no such hits materialised for which I was thankful. Then I slept right through until 1030am on Sunday, and was hit with a CH attack a few minutes later. It was very weak, and went away in under 15mins. So I went shopping, drove 6 miles to the supermarket, go through the door and got hit with something approaching a 7. Was hard to think straight, then the bradycardia kicked in and a couple of times my legs almost bucked. Got the the checkout 30mins later, pouring of sweat and barely able to speak, the woman there must have thought I was a junkie... Then as I exited the building the attack suddenly cleared up, leaving me with the endorphin thingm so fell into the car and dazed it out for a few minutes before driving. Head gave me no trouble for the rest of the day, through until 3am Monday. Then I got hit with a series of K5s and K6s with a 30min attack every 2 hours whilst sleeping. Managed to sleep through the 5s - just, but had to tough out the 6s. Then got hit again at 1330 with a kip 4 that lasted 30 minutes. Head feels OK now. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by rickyshot on Aug 7th, 2006, 10:31am God Flash I am a complicated migraineur too and they are very stubborn and sometimes worse than the ch as they go on for days to weeks. I am praying the baby woodrose seeds will bring some help in prevention and abortion of those as well. You still seem to be having a crappy time of it all. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by unsolved1 on Aug 7th, 2006, 10:40am Sorry for my ignorance ::) But I was under the impression that Flash was one of the biggest supporters and/or creator/contributor to clusterbusters and that mushrooms were his treatment of choice. Do the mushrooms help you or not ? Did they use to but have since failed ? What happened ? PF Wishes UNsolved |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by seasonalboomer on Aug 7th, 2006, 10:49am on 08/07/06 at 10:40:46, unsolved1 wrote:
Michael, Early in this thread (or the previous) Flash mentioned that his supply had been damaged beyond use and he was therefore experimenting until a new supply can be made ready. As you may know, laws in the UK have changed in recent past and therefore all of our friends in the UK have the same laws we must deal with here, and the same care required in acquiring their treatment of choice. Scott |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by pattik on Aug 7th, 2006, 10:59am I would also just like to add to what Scott said, that Flash is applying the same pioneering spirit with which he discovered the use of shrooms for CH to "manageing" CH without meds. Sharing his experiences with us (good or bad) as they are happening, is very unselfish as well as helpful to some of us, IMO. Thanks Flash. Patti |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by LeLimey on Aug 7th, 2006, 11:35am Flash did you try the green tea at all? Or was the nausea from the migraine making that impossible. It sound slike an awful weekend, I'm so sorry. I really hope this was your cycle peaking. You mention trying to sleep through hits, did you try your usual routine or were you too tired? It sounded a very intense night. I'm just trying to get a picture of how everything worked or didn't work in relation to before if I'm not explaining myself clearly Helen |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by Flash on Aug 7th, 2006, 12:17pm To put everything in perspective: The Saturday migraine would average out as a Kip3 for 22 hours. So total pain score = 66. But it was a very tolerable 66. A selection of CH attacks totalling 66 would have felt a lot worse. Not really a straight comparison. The Sunday pain score was 3.5. Last night was approx 10 plus another 2 today. So today so far = 12. Remember that my worst ever day was 196! So this whole episode has been a total breeze relatively speaking, with most hits being kip 5 and last 30 minutes, and an average of only 3 hits per day. I can do that standing on my head. You get used to it. My shrooms were destoryed after I foolishly tried to dry them in the oven - WTF was I thinking LOL??? Mind you it wasn't my idea... At home I have some RC seeds and 3g dried cubensis. Neither of which I have tried before. I'm saving these in case things get silly. It's been 3 years since my last episode and the shrooms have been so sucessful that I have been unable to contribute too much. So this time I'm hoping to acheive the following: 1) Since my last dose of shrooms in April 2003 I have experienced several phantom episodes. This episode has been incredibly soft thus far and it started off like a phantom. Has it now some sort of half assed hybrid between a phantom and a regular episode? I've yet to experience a full on Kip 7, so I suspect this may be the case. 2) Does green tea help? So far this is looking like a yes, but I cannot rule out hot water working as well. 3) If i do get a 196 day then I'm going to ask Laura to video record me for posterity. 4) Can CH be managed without meds. Well this episode has been very soft, but so far, yes I have been able to abort the majority of attacks without meds. My results are probably equivalent to the best prescription abortives. But like I suspect this may not be a full on episode. But hey ho at least we're learning something. 5) If I do reach peak, then will the seeds be effective on a 196 day? Please God I'm not really sure I want to find out LOL. The green tea did not help with the migraine, neither did exercise. A hot shower helped a bit while my head was under the water, and chewing ice on the affected side worked best of all. But the green tea continues to help with the other attacks. Hope this answers everyones questions. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by unsolved1 on Aug 7th, 2006, 12:25pm Thanks for the info guys and gals :) And Flash ... sorry about the supply 'disruption'. If the shrooms help you alot ... I hope you get your hands on some soon. Until then, hang tough and good luck. Hopefully you'll be spared from the killer hits. UNsolved |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by Flash on Aug 9th, 2006, 12:04pm Yesterday went smoothly with no further attacks. Didn't get hit until 6am, but managed to abort in under 30 mins. Should have just got up, but the aftermath sent me to LA LA land, and on entering the next REM phase got hit again at 8am. Same again, and got hit at 9.30am. That last one was the worst. Since then some nasty shadows and a little tenderness. Will count today as a pain score of 18 so far. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by kcopelin on Aug 9th, 2006, 6:23pm So Flash, thank you for sharing your experiences with us all. It gives me hope when I see someone dealing with CHs medication free. I am on the thrid day of vicodin withdrawal, and I have to tell you, this sucks bad. Think I will start a thread on this, as newbies really need to be warned about this. PFDAN kathy |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by Flash on Aug 11th, 2006, 7:55am The 10th started off with some morning hits, the first at 6am was mild and didn't trouble me at all. The second indicated that it was time to get up, this was at 7.30am. So I got up, ate breakfast, showered etc, the hit aborted within 20 mins. Then a small hit occurred at 10am, but again managed to abort this within 20 mins. The rest of the day was great, my head felt clear, and I suspected this thing was on the way out. Went to bed at midnight totally PF... Pain score for the day would be 5. Then was awakened at 1am with the start of a night from hell. Reckon the attacks made it up to 7/8 but still thankfully no dental involvement. I kept falling asleep on entering Llaland at the end of each hit, and then going back into REM and trigerring a back-to-back attack. So all in I went through 4x90min- 2 hour attacks lasting till 8am. I managed another hour of sleep until 9am then had to get up for a meeting. So I'm going to count the pain score for today so far as approx 50 which is my worst day yet. Still feeling tender. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by pattik on Aug 11th, 2006, 8:04am Thanks for the update. I was wondering if you have noticed an every-other day thing going on, in regards to increased activity vs a quiet day? I have noticed in the past that it would be common for me to have a fairly pain-free 24 hours following a particularly high level group of headaches. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by Sandy_C on Aug 12th, 2006, 10:38am Flash, thanks for posting the daily reports. Because of family history health issues, I am now choosing not to use any prescription meds (even though I do have trex on hand). I've been doing a monthly maintenance dose of rc seeds, but as of yesterday afternoon, am showing signs of beginning a new cycle (been PF for one year). Dosed last night with seeds, and am still shadowing today. If I try your suggestions, I need to be off everything, including the seeds for at least a month - correct? I'm going shopping for some green tea today! Sounds promising. Please keep posting. Wishing you a pain level day of 0. Sandy |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by kcopelin on Aug 12th, 2006, 11:12am Flash, I think someone might have asked but can't find it....are you using O2? I am so thankful for you-you give each of us hope, a different perspective and I really appreciate that. I am so rooting for you, that you kick this beast right between the eyes! Thanks again, PFDAN kathy |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by Flash on Aug 14th, 2006, 1:19am Not using O2. Sat morning got around 2 hours sleep. Went all day without any attacks until 0245 Sunday which hit level 9. Was in the emergency room by 5am due to bradycardia, unfortunately this symptom was gone by the time I got there. Did get an ECG and a chest X-ray and everything apparently OK there. This was just routine as they were pretty sure it was just CH related, and I have had this several times in the past. Never pleasant though. They (finally) gave me O2 at 12lpm on a non-rebreather, which took the edge off the CH. Do not have this at home though, was just hooked up in the cell... sorry examination room. And here's the good part - I've lain in that same fuckin cell on at least 3 other occasions with some facist/sadist in a white coat telling me that they don't have fuckin O2, and there it was, plugged into the wall all this time, plus another tank under the strecher for backup. But then again the wanker knew that as I had my eyes closed it would not be possible for me to have seen this. Hey ho at least I got a shot of it this time. Have now had a migraine lingering for 24 hours. Not a good day. Hope to fuck this was the peak... BTW - how's this for shitty. They refused to give me any water until the Doctor saw me, which was about 2 hours later. A high level attack like that causes me to sweat buckets and I was very dehydrated which did not help the situation. Plus being in photophobic mode I had wrapped a cloth round my head so was to all intents voluntarily blind. Tried explaining to the thingy... I mean bitch... I mean hard nosed cow... I mean nazi/nurse that this was a CH attack and it was totally wrong to deny me water because dehydration could make things much worse. But she just gave me the get back in your cell and don't take that tone of voice with me you fucking freak treatment. Should have remembered to type out my CH manifesto and take it with me. I'll try and get the neurologist to sign it, so that I can deal with nazis while experiencing high intensity hits. Full marks to the duty doctor though, he was the best I have ever encountered in A&E. Hope I get the smae dude next time. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by LeLimey on Aug 14th, 2006, 5:21am I'm sorry Flash, that was horrible for you. Its good news about the ECG at least Hope you get some PF time soon Helen |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by kcopelin on Aug 14th, 2006, 5:54pm Aw Flash, I'm so sorry to hear this-I hope it was the peak of your cycle too. Take care my friend. Prayers for PFDAN! kathy |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by Flash on Aug 14th, 2006, 7:33pm Migraine ended up lasting 36 hours, finally terminating at around 6pm. Feel great now though! Be interesting to see if I am permitted to sleep tonight. No great loss if I can't since I slept a long time today, not much else to do when you have a migraine but sleep. So that would be the worst spell yet. We'll rate Sunday as: 1 hour at 2 of shadow + 2 hours at 9 of main CH brain melter with bradycardia which I'm almost tempted to add exra points for... + 18 hours at 5(ish) with the migraine = 110. Still waaay better than my 196 experience. And today was 66, but all of that from the tail end of the migraine. Check back a couple of posts cos I've edited in the full details now that I feel better. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by Flash on Aug 14th, 2006, 7:48pm on 08/12/06 at 10:38:38, Sandy_C wrote:
Personally I'd stick with the seeds. This is just an experiement and might help people to detox, or when they encounter dosing/viability issues. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by Flash on Aug 18th, 2006, 4:38am Hit with managable night time attack on Monday and Tuesday, 2 attacks each night. Not much activity during the day so we're down to pain scores of around 10. Wednesday slept right through but woke up with a minor hit at 8am, and had more attachs at 10am and noon. The shadowed several times, and got another small hit at 6pm. Total socre for the day was around 15. But last night slep right through and have awoken with only some tenderness. Starting to suspect that this episode is on the way out. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by Flash on Aug 21st, 2006, 6:14am Friday night Saturday morning had to go to A&E again, after 2 hours of a bad attack, not quite as bad as the lat time though. Only got as far as the waiting room when it started to dissipate, so no treatment required. Saturday and Sunday were then clear apart from a mild attack in the morning, barely more than a shadow. This morning got up to K4 for a half hour. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by LeLimey on Aug 21st, 2006, 6:28am Hi Flash, Thanks for the update - I have a couple of questions! How does this cycle relate to previous ones, length, severity etc? Do you feel going "unmedicated" would be worth trying again next time? (ie no alternatives) How do you feel in yourself compared to other cycles? Do you feel you are coping better? You're more positive or not? I don't mean in the middle of each hit because none of us "cope" then, I'm talking about your state of mind throughout the day or week. Thanks Helen |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by Flash on Aug 22nd, 2006, 8:54am on 08/21/06 at 06:28:53, LeLimey wrote:
It's been a doddle. Although overall the episode has lasted longer, it took forever to get going, so probably had close to a month of harbringers and totally mild attacks before the shit hit the fan. Usually the whole thing was over in 1 month. The duration of the attacks has mostly been far shorter. Have experienced less than 10 bad attacks. on 08/21/06 at 06:28:53, LeLimey wrote:
No I will secure shrooms in the next couple of months and have a long break from CH. This is only an alterantive to conventional meds. If I had shrooms then I would have used them. Due out my 2 year old bag od dried and they had gone soft so elected no to risk it. on 08/21/06 at 06:28:53, LeLimey wrote:
Well the episode has coincided with a health drive, so overall I'm feeling great, much better than 2 months ago. My state of mind and body is the best it's been in almost 5 years. Once the episode stops then I'll debrief fully. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by Margi on Aug 22nd, 2006, 10:22am Flash, just a question....are you going to try the seeds at all this cycle? It sounds like you would be a great candidate being totally detoxed and it just might kick it out the door for you. Sorry to hear you've had such a rough go. :( |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by Flash on Aug 25th, 2006, 8:00am No I'm just going to ride it out. If I were going to try something new to me like seeds then I would probably try them as preventative rather than to break a cycle. That way I get to safely experiment with dosage etc while the heat is off. Since the last bad attack onlt shadows, and typically around 4 hours of them midday till late afternoon. They come and go. Been getting less each day though. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by kcopelin on Aug 25th, 2006, 10:03am Flash, you are one brave son of a gun! thank you kathy |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by Flash on Aug 28th, 2006, 7:37am It seems to be over. |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by mynm156 on Aug 28th, 2006, 7:46am on 08/04/06 at 10:40:16, LeLimey wrote:
I do not think that it is a problem. Supplimental Oxygen will be out of your system within about 20mins. mynm156 |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by LeeS on Aug 30th, 2006, 1:09pm on 08/28/06 at 07:37:31, Flash wrote:
I hope so Flash. Your round then? -Lee |
||||||
Title: Re: Can CH be managed? Post by seasonalboomer on Aug 30th, 2006, 2:22pm on 08/28/06 at 07:37:31, Flash wrote:
Hey Flash, Don't do that again okay? It was almost painful to read --- It's been a almost a couple years since I "rode one out" and you were giving me flashbacks....... Take care of your arsenal so you don't have to do it again. Glad its over for you. Scott |
||||||
Clusterheadaches.com Message Board » Powered by YaBB 1 Gold - SP 1.3.1! YaBB © 2000-2003. All Rights Reserved. |